Jump to Navigation

Birmingham AL Personal Injury Blog

Alabama Court Clarifies Wrongful Death Law

  • 21
  • February
    2012

In a previous post, we reported that the Alabama Supreme Court changed a century of wrongful death law by allowing a claim to be made for a fatal injury to an unborn child. On the heels of that decision, Mack v. Carmack, the Court has again addressed the issue and provided guidance as to the type of damages that can be claimed.

Typically, the only damages that may be awarded in an Alabama wrongful death claim are punitive in nature, designed to punish the Defendant and/or deter others from acting the same way. But, in the most recent case of Hamilton v. Scott, a medical malpractice claim, the mother made a claim for emotional distress, separate and apart from the normal punitive damages claim in death cases.

The Court, relying on relevant precedent, ruled that the trial court properly dismissed the emotional distress count because the mother did not prove a separate physical injury to her. The mother had previously argued that her unborn child was part of her. But the Court held that, based on older case law, a fetus is a separate entity with a "separate existence" from the mother. Based on this decision, it appears that the Alabama Supreme Court will continue to limit fatal injury claims to the punitive damages recoverable in wrongful death actions. 

Even though the Hamilton v. Scott case involved medical malpractice issues, suits for fatal injuries to a fetus can be brought in any number of situations, including car accidents, on-the-job accidents or injury caused by a defective product.

I-20 Car Accident Caused by Tire Blow-Out

  • 17
  • February
    2012

The Birmingham New has reported that a car crash occurred on I-20 Wednesday, resulting in at least one fatality. At least one source has indicated that a tire blow-out led to the accident, which also resulted in a collision with an 18 wheeler.

Many people are unaware that car accidents, due to tire blow-outs, hydroplaning, road construction defects, fallen debris or stray animals, make up approximately half of all motor vehicle accident deaths and injuries. While alcohol or distracted driving can be a contributing factor, many of these one vehicle accidents result in severe and catastrohpic injury due to faulty airbags or seat belts.

In previous posts, we have discussed the different personal injury claims that can be made when a car accident occurs. In those instances where the at-fault driver is uninsured, the injured party can draw upon their own insurance for uninsured motorist benefits. Or, if a defect in the car caused the accident or contributed to the enhanced injury (i.e. seatbelt failure), a products liability claim can be made against the auto manufacturer.

The investigation is still underway with regard to the 1-20 accident reported by the Birmingham News. But, tire blow-out injury claims against the tire manufacturer are fairly common when a defect in the tire is identified.

If you have been in an auto accident where the safety features failed to perform properly, you may have a claim against the manufacturer for your injuries and damages.

Truck Drivers and Sleep Apnea, a Dangerous Combination

  • 15
  • February
    2012

An 18-wheeler traveling down a dark freeway and a sleepy driver can be a dangerous combination. Trucking companies regulate how many hours their drivers can be behind the wheel each day to encourage adequate rest. But, is ensuring the drivers have enough time to sleep enough to ensure they are not driving drowsy? A recent study on sleep apnea and the occurrence of accidents suggests that having eight hours to rest may not be enough to ensure alertness.

Sleep apnea is a breathing disorder that affects as many as one in 15 individuals. However, many of these individuals are not aware that they suffer from the disorder. There are no blood tests for diagnosing the disorder and the telltale symptoms are often overlooked.

Personal Injury Litigation in Alabama - Overview

  • 13
  • February
    2012

While most personal injury claims settle, particularly auto accident claims, a small minority must be filed in the circuit courts of Alabama. Once filed, the Defendant's insurance carrier must hire an attorney to defend the claim. Because of budget cuts in the court system, it can take as long as two to three years before a suit is tried to a jury.

Once the Defendant has filed an answer to the complaint, a status conference is generally scheduled between the judge and attorneys. At this conference, issues are to discussed and a scheduling order is entered. The scheduling order will usually set cut-offs for depositions, discovery and exchanging witness and exhibit list. Also, a trial date will be set and the parties will work toward the trial date.

Personal injury litigation can involve many things, and the attorney will have to make sure the case is properly prepared for trial. This can inlcude:

* Deposition of the Defendant

* Ordering all medical records and bills

* Deposition of the Plaintiff's treating physician(s)

* Hiring expert witnesses in complex cases

* Depositions of all eyewitnesses

* Trial briefs for the judge

* Multiple motions to compel production of documents from the Defendant

* Subpoenas to non-parties

At some point, the court will often order the parties to mediation to see if the case can settle. Mediation, unlike arbitration, is a voluntary process where a certified mediator will try to get the parties to settle by making suggestions and offering opinions about the settlement value of the claim.

Once a trial date is set, it is not set in stone. Continuances are very common, due to illness of a party, unavailable witnesses, etc. It is common for a case to be set several times before it is heard by a jury. The key here is patience...eventually, the court system, even with budget cuts, will eventually push the case to trial.

Wrongful Death Suit Filed Against City of Birmingham

  • 08
  • February
    2012

Court records show that a wrongful death claim has been filed against the City of Birmingham as a result of a pedestrian accident involving a police officer. Recent posts on our blog have noted an upward trend in the incidence of auto and truck accidents involving pedestrians.

Historically, Alabama government agencies and cities have been immune from suit for personal injury. The State of Alabama still enjoys this immunity. However, changes over the last few decades have opened the door, very slightly, to certain types of claims. Still, claims against counties and states have numerous hurdles and restrictions.

Before a lawsuit can be filed against a city or county, a "notice of claim", itemizing the injuries, damages, and amount being claimed, has to be filed within a narrow time range(6 months for cities, one year for counties). Almost always, the claim is denied and a lawsuit follows.

Moreover, claims against a city are capped at $100,000. This means that if the Mayor of Birmingham t-bones a citizen while driving his official car, the most Birmingham's liability insurance carrier would have to pay is $100,000...even if the victim has hundreds of thousands of dollars in medical bills! The cap also applies to wrongful death claims. Efforts to raise this absurd cap have fallen short in the Alabama legislature year afer year. 

If you have been injured in an auto accident by the negligence of an employee of a city or county, don't delay in seeking guidance from a personal injury attorney.

Alabama Workplace Accidents

  • 03
  • February
    2012

Workplace accidents are very common in Alabama. The process usually involves notice to your employer, then you are given permission to go to the emergency room. You miss a few days from work and that's it. But what about severe and catastrophic injuries that result in a lifetime disability? Unfortunately, for most Alabama workers, worker's compensation benefits are meager and insufficient for long term needs.

However, there are a few options for those situations where the injury is permanent and debilitating. We are referring to "third-party" claims against someone other than the employer. These claims arise when an injury is caused by a non-employer.

Examples of potential third-parties include:

a. subcontractors

b. product manufacturers

c. supervisory co-employees

d. fabricators or installers of injury-causing machinery

e. parent company of the employer

To see how this works, let's use the following example: you are asked to drive your supervisor's car to Birmingham to make a delivery. You leave from ABC Company in Cullman, traveling I-65. On the way, an 18 wheeler owned by XYZ Company sideswipes you, causing a major car crash. Seriously injured, you are transported to UAB with permanent injuries that prevent you from working at your job.

In the above example, you can receive workers comp benefits from the insurance carrier for ABC Company and maintain a suit against XYZ Company for all the things Alabama's workers comp doesn't provide, such as compensation for future lost wages, loss of earning capacity, mental anguish, pain and suffering, etc.

If you have been injured on-the-job, don't ignore the possiblity of hiring an Alabama workplace accidents lawyer to assist you in getting full compensation for your claims.  

Proof of Personal Injury in an Alabama Car Wreck Claim

  • 01
  • February
    2012

If you have been injured in a car accident, the insurance company will want copies of your medical records and bills in order to substantiate your injury. However, a doctor's notes will rarely specifically state opinions about medical causation. Therefore, it can become difficult to convince the insurance adjuster that your personal injury was directly attributable to the accident.

Alabama law generally requires expert testimony to establish medical causation in car accidents claims. The exception is when the injury is obvious and even a layperson could relate it to the accident(i.e. seatbelt bruise across the chest).

In the majority of cases, you must prove, through your treating physician, that the claimed injury was "probably" caused by the accident. Not "maybe" or "possibly", but more likely than not. Since the doctor will rarely offer such an opinion in his notes, a car wreck attorney is often needed to obtain a deposition of the doctor so medical causation opinions can be obtained.

Also, be aware that not all accident-related injuries are immediately apparent. Some injuries, such as spinal disc problems, may not surface for several months or years. This is another reason you may need a specialist and diagnostic tests to give you peace of mind that when you settle, you haven't missed a hidden or latent injury.

If you have been involved in a auto accident and need legal assistance with proving your personal injury damages, contact a qualified Birmingham injury lawyer to discuss your options. Remember, for most accident claims, there is a two-year statute of limitations.

Alabama Wrongful Death Law

  • 30
  • January
    2012

Alabama's wrongful death law is materially and fundamentally different from the law of every other jurisdiction. Unlike most fatal injury claims, the focus is not on the individual who died but rather on the conduct of the at-fault defendant. Whereas other states' law addresses the financial loss caused to the family and dependents, Alabama's law reverses it and disallows "compensation" to the survivors.

The allowed compensation for the family in most other states consists of: lost income, loss of companionship, funeral and burial expenses, etc.  Alabama courts have traditionally reasoned that placing a monetary value on a human life is wrong. Under its law, the only money that can be awarded to the family is in the form of punitive damages, based on the degree of reprehensiblity of the defendant's actions. In short, the jury is asked to punish the defendant and award an amount of money that will deter others from committing the same act.

As an example, in a fatal trucking accident case where the at-fault driver is overloaded and rear-ends an automobile, the jury would be told to punish the driver and his company for failing to comply with DOT regs establishing maximum load weight.

Finally, Alabama's wrongful death law provides that the money recovered by suit or settlement cannot be used to pay any of the debts of the deceased. Nor does the money pass into the estate of the victim. Instead, it is given directly to the heirs, regardless of whether the deceased had a will.

About Drake Law Firm - Feel free to visit our main website to browse any topics you may be interested in. Our Birmingham wrongful death attorneys will be happy to answer any questions you may have.

Recent Alabama Pedestrian Accidents

  • 23
  • January
    2012

A series of recent Alabama pedestrian accidents have hi-lighted the need for strict enforcement of crosswalk right-of-ways and better public education. Early last month a University of Alabama at Huntsville student was hit while coming back from class. Before that, in 2011, a jogger was hit while running in Mountain Brook. Finally, a tragic accident occurred in Mobile when a police officer struck a husband and wife, killing the man and  leaving the woman permanently disabled.

Pedestrian accidents with cars are not uncommon, particularly in urban or residential areas where autos and walkers share the streets. Efforts have been made to clearly define walkways for pedestrians and warn drivers of their presence.

In any claim against an auto driver, it must be shown that they were negligent before a recovery can be had for personal injury compensation. "Negligence" is the failure of the driver to keep a reasonable look-out for foreseeable pedestrians.

The above mentioned accident in Mobile is disturbing because it involved a city police officer, who, by virtue of Alabama laws capping claims against municpalities, cannot be resposible for more than $100,000 in damages, regardless of the severity of the injuries caused. A Mobile county grand jury cleared the officer of any criminal conduct but a claim for civil liability has been filed against him.

If you have been injured and need a pedestrian accident attorney, remember that Alabama has a two year statute of limitations, plus a 6-month notice of claim requirement in cases against municipalities.

Safety of New DOT Rule Questioned

  • 19
  • January
    2012

The US Department of Transportation (DOT) announced a rule revising commercial truck driver hours of service (HOS). It employs the latest in driver fatigue research to ensure those operating commercial vehicles on the nation's roadways are well rested, according to a DOT News Release. The rule is designed to increase highway safety and decrease the number of truck accidents.

Rule Specifics

The original rule allowed truckers to work 82 hours per week. The new rule reduces the total by 12 hours, but allows the current 11 hour work day to remain. The rule also includes a mandatory overnight rest period between the hours of one and five a.m.

The changes are based on "the most extensive and transparent public outreach effort in our agency's history," according to the DOT's Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration.

 

AV | Lexis Nexis | Martindale Hubbell | Peer Review Rated For Ethical Standards and Legal Ability AVVO | www.avvo.com

Free case evaluation

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close